What Didn’t Work For Me

I went to AA properly. I went consistently, in different countries, and I went with genuine willingness rather than sitting at the back waiting to prove that it was not for me. There were meetings I found moving and people I respected enormously. The fellowship itself is real, and so is one of the ideas at its centre: somebody who has lived through addiction can sometimes reach another person in a way that professional expertise alone cannot.

What did not work for me was the particular container. The language of a higher power, surrender and powerlessness never became natural to me, however much I tried to translate it into something I could believe. I understood what people meant when they told me I did not have to take the language literally, but eventually I had to accept that repeatedly trying to make myself fit the framework was not helping.

That is not the same as saying AA does not work. It plainly does for many people, including people whose recovery I admire. It just was not where mine took hold.

What Did Work

There was no single replacement. What worked was a combination of things that gradually made my life more stable and made returning to drugs and alcohol less necessary.

I had a psychiatrist I trusted and saw consistently. I began to understand more about what was happening in my own brain and behaviour, rather than treating every difficult impulse as evidence of some moral failure. Routine mattered more than I expected: sleeping properly, exercising, eating, having somewhere to be, and slowly rebuilding days that did not revolve around either using or recovering from using.

The part I remember most clearly, though, was wanting someone who had actually been through their own version of it and could exist in my ordinary life. Not only for an appointment, and not only in a room where recovery was the explicit subject. I wanted someone who understood why a dinner, an airport, an empty Sunday or a particular group of friends could suddenly make everything feel much less straightforward than it had an hour earlier.

That person was not really there for me. It is one of the experiences that eventually shaped the way I work now.

Recovery Does Not Have to Look One Way

One of the things I wish I had understood earlier is that rejecting one model does not mean rejecting recovery. AA is one route. SMART Recovery offers a secular approach built around behavioural tools and mutual support. Therapy, psychiatry, medication, peer support, structured treatment and combinations of all of them can play different roles for different people.

What seems much more important to me now is whether the support is something a person can genuinely engage with. A theoretically excellent model is not very useful if somebody feels alienated by its language, cannot imagine themselves belonging there, or keeps attending while privately believing that the whole thing is happening to somebody else.

That is where I think the conversation about AA can become unnecessarily binary. People can end up defending it or attacking it when the more useful question is whether this particular person has found something they can actually use. Recovery is difficult enough without turning the method into another test of character.

What This Means in My Work

I am not anti-AA. If somebody I work with goes to meetings, values them and wants them to remain part of their recovery, I will support that. If AA has not worked for them, I am equally uninterested in telling them that they simply did it incorrectly or were not willing enough.

My own work is secular and one-to-one. Sometimes it looks like recovery coaching, with regular conversations, structure and attention to the patterns that keep repeating. Sometimes it becomes sober companionship, with more presence in the parts of somebody’s actual life where maintaining change is difficult. It can sit alongside therapy, psychiatry, treatment, fellowship or other support rather than asking to replace them.

I also do not assume that everybody who contacts me has already decided that lifelong abstinence is their answer. Sometimes that becomes clear quite quickly. Sometimes somebody wants to understand whether moderation is realistic, why previous attempts have not held, or what alcohol or drugs are doing for them before they decide what they want to do about it.

I know what it is like to keep trying to make yourself fit a recovery model because you assume the model must be right and therefore you must be the problem. In my case, things changed when I stopped asking how to become better at somebody else’s version of recovery and started working out what would actually hold in my own life.