Most students arrive at the University of Cambridge having been among the cleverest people in the room. Within a fortnight, many of them no longer are. Nobody has become less able. The room has changed, and everyone in it was the cleverest person somewhere else.

For many students this is the first time they have felt average, or below average, at the thing they have always been good at. The feeling that follows has a name. The psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes first described the impostor phenomenon in 1978, in a study of high-achieving women: a persistent belief, despite clear evidence of ability, that you have got where you are by luck or mistake and will sooner or later be found out. At Cambridge it is common, and rarely said out loud.

The admissions mistake

There is an old joke at Cambridge about being the admissions mistake. Freshers make it in the first week, laugh about it, and then privately half believe it for the next three years.

The belief tends to sharpen when you feel visibly different from the person you imagine a Cambridge student to be. That might mean being the first in your family to go to university, coming from a state school into a room of people who seem fluent in a world you are only learning, arriving from another country, being older than everyone else, or being neurodivergent in a system that does not seem built for the way you work. None of these makes you less entitled to be there. They can make it much harder to feel it.

Supervisions make it personal

At most universities you can stay anonymous in a lecture hall. At Cambridge you meet a supervisor every week, often with one or two other students, to discuss work they have read closely.

The anxiety usually starts before the first supervision. You read the question several times and are still not sure what it wants. The reading seems to assume knowledge you do not have. You hand in something you know is not finished and spend the next few days expecting to be found out. Then, in the room, everyone else seems to have read more, understood more and have something clever to say. In the first weeks of term, that is enough to convince a lot of very able students that they are not good enough to be there.

A supervisor pushing hard on an argument is doing their job. To a student already unsure whether they belong, it can feel like a verdict, and the student beside you who seems to answer easily appears to confirm it.

Directors of Studies, college tutors and supervisors are mostly trying to help, and many are very good at it. But between them they also set the work, follow your progress and write your references, which makes them difficult people to tell that you think you should not be there.

Everyone performing that they are fine

What does most damage at Cambridge is the silence around the doubt. Everyone appears to be coping. People mention how much they have left to do in a tone that suggests they will get it done. Being up until 3am becomes a kind of credential. Social media fills with formals, punting and May Balls.

What goes unsaid is how many of the people in those photographs are struggling too. When everyone performs being able to cope, each person concludes they are the only one who cannot. That is deeply isolating, and it is often the isolation, more than the work, that does the harm.

I saw this from an unusual angle. I was at Cambridge as a mature student in my late thirties, alongside people half my age, and I spent a lot of time with students late at night, often in the week before exams. The conversations were remarkably similar. Very capable people, each sure they were the only one finding it hard.

I had my own version of it, as a neurodivergent student in a place that seemed designed for a different kind of brain. I graduated with a First. The doubt did not disappear because of that. I just stopped treating it as evidence.

What it does to the work

Imposter feelings rarely stay as feelings. They tend to show up as behaviour. Perfectionism, where nothing is good enough to hand in. Procrastination, because starting means finding out whether you can do it. Not asking questions in supervisions in case the question reveals too much. Skipping the supervision altogether when the essay is not ready.

Each of these makes the work harder, and the harder work then looks like proof that you were right about yourself all along. It is a loop, and it is easier to interrupt early in term than late.

What helps

Naming it helps more than people expect. Knowing that imposter syndrome is common at Cambridge does not make it go away, but it changes how far you believe it.

It also helps to separate the feeling from the evidence. Cambridge admissions is a long, demanding process designed specifically so that people do not get through it by luck. You can feel like a mistake and still not be one.

Go to the supervision with the unfinished essay. Ask the question you think is obvious. Tell one person, a friend, a tutor, someone in your college, that you are finding it hard. The answer is very often “me too”, and that answer does more than any amount of reassurance.

Your Director of Studies, your tutor, the college nurse and the University Counselling Service are all there for this, and imposter feelings are not too small a reason to use them. For some students it also helps to have one consistent person outside the University, who understands Cambridge but plays no part in assessing them. I offer independent online mentoring for Cambridge students on exactly that basis: one hour a week by video, at £75, for the practical side of term and for the doubts that are hard to say out loud inside college. If you are in your first term, I have also written about what the first term at Cambridge is really like. If you are an international student, I also offer private support for students studying away from home.

When it is more than doubt

Sometimes what looks like imposter syndrome is sitting on top of something heavier: low mood that does not lift, not sleeping, panic, or stopping eating properly. If that is you, speak to your college nurse, your GP or the University Counselling Service. If you are ever at immediate risk, contact emergency services, or call Samaritans on 116 123, at any hour. I have written more about this in Struggling at Cambridge.

You are almost certainly not the only person in your supervision group who feels like an imposter. You may just be the first to say so.